Ivan IV and William Marshal arrived with Rise of Kingdoms version 1.1.11, but they are not two interchangeable upgrades for the same cavalry march. Their skill conditions point in different directions: Ivan is built to do most of his work in the open field, while William unlocks the defining parts of his kit in rallies against cities and structures.
That distinction matters if you already have Arthur Pendragon and Achilles. The new commanders do not automatically make that pair obsolete, and investing in one of them only makes sense if it improves the marches you can actually field.
Ivan IV belongs in the open-field discussion
Ivan's third and fourth skills only activate in an open-field troop, where his kit adds cavalry durability, repeated Combo interactions, and the Terror debuff. This is more than a talent-tree preference. Moving him into a rally turns off two passives that help define why players are considering him in the first place.
The most direct new setup to test is Arthur Pendragon primary with Ivan IV secondary. Arthur already supports a Combo-focused cavalry march, while Ivan adds another set of effects that reward repeated normal and Combo attacks. It is an attractive route for an account that already has Arthur fully developed, because the player is adding one commander rather than rebuilding the whole march.
Ivan can also be tested with Achilles when Achilles is the better-developed or better-equipped partner on the account. That is a practical alternative, not evidence that one order or one partner has already won the long-term comparison. The release is too recent for that kind of conclusion.
Arthur and Achilles remain the established high-end open-field pairing, and their existing performance is not erased by Ivan's arrival. If you run only one cavalry march, keeping them together is still a defensible choice while more matched battle reports accumulate.
The more interesting case is a player who can support two cavalry marches. Arthur/Ivan can become the new Combo march while Achilles moves beside Gang Gamchan, but this split only adds value if both marches have competitive equipment, armaments, troops, and battlefield roles. Two commander pairs on a roster screen are not the same as two marches that survive focus fire and trade well in KvK.
William Marshal has an open-field option, but it should be treated more cautiously. William/Gang Gamchan is being discussed as a new single-target field pairing, yet its long-term place is still unsettled. William loses the rally-only stacking engine and the structure-only effects that make his complete kit distinctive, so a normal field player should not assume that his partial field value justifies a fresh Legendary Sculpture investment.
William Marshal is a rally decision
William gains Unwavering Spirit while leading a rally, and another passive applies its damage reduction, anti-Archer bonus, and Defense reduction only while attacking a city or structure. His later Combo trigger consumes those Unwavering Spirit stacks. Those conditions make William a specialist for players who are expected to launch important cavalry rallies, not a general replacement for an open-field commander.
William Marshal with Subutai is the clearest rally pairing to watch because both commanders fit a cavalry Combo rally plan. Even then, the pairing is not a plug-and-play ranking. Rally results depend on the target garrison, kingdom technology, equipment, armaments, troop capacity, alliance buffs, and the rules of the current KvK.
William/Ivan may look appealing because both use Combo attacks, but the shared label hides a role conflict. Ivan loses his two open-field-only passives inside a rally, so William/Ivan should remain a test case rather than the default recommendation until transparent rally reports show what it gains in return.
For anyone who is not an alliance rally leader, William is therefore difficult to justify as the first response to this update. A commander whose best effects appear in content you rarely lead can be powerful without being a good investment for your account.
Should an Arthur/Achilles account invest now?
For a one-march open-field account, the answer is usually not yet. Keep Arthur/Achilles intact unless Ivan can be developed without delaying another core commander and you have a specific reason to change the march, such as better field trades in your own tests or a second partner that would otherwise sit unused.
For a developed two-march cavalry account, Ivan is the more relevant new investment to test. The account should already have enough Legendary Sculptures to reach the intended build, a second competitive cavalry equipment and armament set, and a credible partner for Achilles after Arthur moves to Ivan. Without those pieces, the investment changes names but may not improve the complete field lineup.
For a dedicated rally account, evaluate William separately from Ivan. William/Subutai is the role-aligned candidate, but only matched tests against the garrisons your alliance expects to face can establish whether the new rally is worth replacing an existing one.
The timing is the final constraint. Less than a week after the update arrived, current pairing guidance still describes the exact placement of Ivan IV and William Marshal as unsettled. Their skill text is strong enough to separate open field from rally now; it is not enough to declare a permanent cavalry ranking.
If you later decide to top up Rise of Kingdoms, FlashMunk currently shows 22% off, with multiple secure payment methods and 24/7 customer support.

